Sunday, September 08, 2002

The perils and pitfalls of definitions

It is the nature of definitions that they limit.

How ironic, it seems, that trying to pin down a definition of homeschooling could impinge on our freedom to homeschool. But that is, in fact, exactly what defining it in law does.

Let's examine, for a moment, the alternative. If we don't define homeschooling, then anyone and everyone can call themselves homeschoolers. It seems a little silly to invite that possibility, yet trying to prevent it by defining homeschooling in law brings certain regulation.

If a state does not allow homeschoolers to self-identify — and by self-identify, I mean that they decide for themselves that they are homeschoolers, rather than having the state determine for them whether they are or not — then the state is regulating homeschooling in some way. In other words, if the state is not simply taking a homeschooling parent's word for it that they are educating their children, then the state is requiring homeschoolers to jump through one or more regulatory hoops to demonstrate or prove that they fit the state's definition of homeschooling.

We can't have zero regulation if homeschoolers are not allowed to self-identify. It's a messy reality.

Saturday, September 07, 2002

Monday, August 26, 2002

Homeschooling News Links

Boston Globe Magazine
Encounter: Joe Perry

St. Petersburg Times
No place like home

Times Daily
Enrollment decline costing area schools

Boston Globe
Enlightened path: New school counters MCAS-based mentality

Sunday, August 25, 2002

Accelerated Unschooling

I have always equated unschooling with simply living one's life in a mindful way, free from the shoulds, oughts, tests, timetables and other prescriptions and proscriptions of the schooling world. So when a concept like accelerated unschooling comes along, I am truly dumbfounded.

Why would anyone want to accelerate life? I snarkily wonder if that would mean you'd end up dying younger. Ha!

Sure, if you or your children are bored, it might be nice to find more interesting things to do. And if you're just not managing to get things done that you really want to do, then arranging some sort of support or schedule to help you focus more on that could be just the ticket.

But the notion of a parent taking over the "motivation" (read "compulsion") aspect of learning because their unschooled child's interests just weren't quite varied enough, and their natural learning pace wasn't fast enough to suit the parent, is altogether different. Not a lot of trust involved there. The only remnants of unschooling in accelerated unschooling appear to be a nod to the child's interests, and maybe a lack of textbook type materials.

More often than not, I find my family wanting to slow down and take everything in, rather than find ways to amuse ourselves more and faster. And the risk is ever present that we might, in our excitement over something, sacrifice depth, understanding, mindfulness, and real connection, for speed and distance traveled.

Accelerated unschooling implies that living and learning is a race. It's not. That concept is totally foreign to our family's unschooling way of life.
California home-school fight goes public

Homeschooling father and attorney Will Rogers sent this heartfelt letter to the Washington Times in response to their coverage of California's intimidation of homeschoolers. His closing paragraph says it all:

"The fundamental right of a parent to direct the education of his or her child is older than the United States Constitution; it is older than recorded history. It is so deeply woven into the fabric of what constitutes a family that to deny this right is to do violence to the sacred bonds that unite a loving mother and father to their beloved child."

Saturday, August 24, 2002

Homeschooling off the grid

I recently had occasion to explain how homeschooling works with our family's traveling lifestyle. Because laws regarding homeschooling vary from state to state, trying to comply with them could easily become a nightmare if we let it. Next time you go out of state on vacation - if you're lucky enough to get to do that - take a peek at how quickly your destination state requires children to be enrolled in school. Most states give you only a week to ten days, and a permanent residence somewhere else isn't any excuse for not complying!

Usually we find ourselves in a situation where it would take longer to comply with the homeschooling law than we would actually be living in the state. A ridiculous predicament, to be sure, and a sad demonstration of the burden homeschoolers in so many states have to bear.

Because we have the great good fortune to live in a free state homeschooling-wise, and can flee oppression elsewhere if the need arises, we have chosen a simpler route. We just go on living our lives, learning as we go, and ignore the legal hoops and chains that would only waste our precious time. In the past I have said that we homeschool underground. But how can I call it that when what we do is so deliberately out-in-the-open, and brings so much joy and light into our lives? We're living blissfully "off the grid" when it comes to school.

Friday, August 23, 2002

A slew of recent articles about homeschooling:

San Antonio Express-News
Home schooling today reaches beyond the house

The Ottawa Citizen (Canada)
Home schooling

TheDay.com
Storytelling family brings legends to life around nation

National Center for Policy Analysis (originally from WA Times)
California prepares to attack home schooling

Insight Magazine
Homeschoolers arrive on campus

Pioneer Press
Plan would shield home-school information

Hendersonville Tribune
'Battle Bots' attack apple festival

USA Today
As home schooling rises, districts fail to meet needs

Peninsula Daily News
Clallam: Homeschool band to help open Clallam County Fair


Sun Herald
Standing room only at homeschool seminar


Frontiersman
School district reaches out


San Diego Union-Tribune
Family finds success with alternative education plan

WXIA TV Atlanta
Home-Schooling Growing as Option

Washington Times
State eyes reducing home-school filings

Wellington Daily News
Bringing in home-schoolers

St. Petersburg Times
Young clogger hoofs her way to Brazil 

New York Times
If School Is Home: Web Help for Age 5

Tampa Tribune
At Home With Science

The Ledger
Disabled Child Home-Schooled With Voucher

Nashua Telegraph
Parents bring award home

Associated Press
Surf's up

Bakersfield Californian
Do-it-yourself school

Computer User Magazine
No place like home
NHEN contributed lots of contacts and info for this one. There's a link to NHEN and a quote from me in it.
Middle of the night is the best time for starting new projects, don't you think? We shall see how it goes.